Humor/ Editorial
Gaming - In General
6 Votes


Hits: 2147
Comments: 12
Ideas: 0
Rating: 3.0833
Condition: Normal
ID: 4805


February 2, 2008, 11:31 am

Vote Hall of Honour

You must be a member to use HoH votes.
Author Status




Why is psuedo-Medieval Tolkien-esque fantasy the heart of the fantasy RPG genre?

The Standard Setting
We’ve seen it a hundred times, the setting is almost the same each time, a lush and green gaming world where elves and dwarves exist, knights and castles rule the land and wizards bend the laws of reality to cast great spells. Of course there are also dragons in the air, and all sorts of races burrowing out the deep places of the earth. It can get old sometimes, but we keep coming back to it, like we keep reading the Lord of the Rings, or plugging in the DVD. The question posed is why? I shall endeavor to answer just that question.

The Call of Fantasy
Fantasy as a genre offers first and foremost an indulgence in Escapism, a chance to ignore the rising gas prices, political turmoil, and day to day hassles of our modern lives. When we create a fantasy character, be it a berzerker or a urbane cleric, we are turning off the modern aspect of life and stepping into a different place. While no one wants to simply walk into Mordor, quite a few would be willing to head down to the Green Dragon or the Prancing Pony to toss back a few cold ones, or research a new sorcerous spell rather than answer the nth business call of the day.

Fantasy generally uses broad strokes to paint in colors of good and evil, the evil oppress and destroy while the good rise up to overthrow those who are wicked. Heroes are heroes, villains are villains, and at the end of the day the heroes rescue the damsel in distress, defeat the dragon, and are cheered when they return to the village.

The races of standard fantasy are solid and well established; humans are versatile, elves are aloof and long lived if not immortal, dwarves are dour and filthy, orcs are bloodthirsty and violent. A dragon is a dragon, a demon is a demon, and so on. While sometimes this familiarity breeds contempt for these races, other races have been brought up into the gaming milieu, each only lasting about as long as the material supporting it but never really escaping that single base. The three races, elves dwarves and orcs, even show up in other genres. The Vulcans and Romulans have the elven look and arrogance and greater lifespans, while Klingons are orcs with an honor bound society and starships.

Para-Feudalism is familiar, the concepts easily understood and since it was centuries in the past, it doesnt change. The structure of nobility and feudalism is a stable system, allowing for long term survival of kingdoms, knightly orders, societies of merchants and magi and all sorts of other nifty things that are popular in gaming circles. In many ways this could be a rejection of more democratic forms of government, characterized by incessant arguement and bickering and politicking. The King makes a decision, those who support it are loyal, those who oppose it are criminals, and that is that.

The Tolkien-esque milieu is solidly represented in the media, from the original books, to the cartoons of the 70s and the LotR trilogy released recently. On top of this, there are thousands upon thousands of paintings of Middle Earth, generic dragon and unicorn pictures, as well as massive amounts of wizardly art and so on. The genre is vibrant and the amount of material supporting it grows daily.

"Heroic fantasy" is the name I have given to a subgenre of fiction, otherwise called the "sword-and-sorcery" story. It is a story of action and adventure laid in a more or less imaginary world, where magic works and where modern science and technology have not yet been discovered. The setting may (as in the Conan stories) be this Earth as it is conceived to have been long ago, or as it will be in the remote future, or it may be another planet or another dimension.

Such a story conbines the color and dash of the historical costume romance with the atavistic supernatural thrills of the weird, occult, or ghost story. When well done, it provides the purest fun of fiction of any kind. It is escape fiction wherein one escapes clear out of the real world into one where all men are strong, all women beautiful, all life adventurous, and all problems simple, and nobody even mentions the income tax or the dropout problem or socialized medicine.
L. Sprague de Camp, introduction to the 1967 Ace edition of Conan.

Deep Roots
It is easy to say that this is all the fault of Dungeons and Dragons and Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings. But the roots of the standard fantasy genre are so much deeper than that. Dungeons and Dragons and Lord of the Rings are just the two most visible and recent influences of a tradition that is more than a millenia old.

Literary Inlfuences
When Professor Tolkien hammered out Lord of the Rings and the Silmarillion he did so in support of a language he was wanting to create, Quenya. He did both, and Quenya is one of the two recognized fantastic languages, the other being Klingon. We are introduced to the Epic in the form of a young hobbit who is entrusted a powerful relic to bear to a strange and hostile land in the face of great opposition to destroy at all costs. We see themes of terrible heroism in the desperate defence of the Hornburg where a scant 300 hold out against 10,000, or when Gandalf the Gray holds a staff and a sword to fight an ancient demon made of living flame and darkness, uttering the line ‘You Shall Not Pass’. Friendship, valor, sacrifice, good, evil, life, and death are all incredibly strong themes. All of these things are largely absent from our daily lives, assuming you arent a firefighter, police officer, or soldier.

But the Professor isnt alone, Robert E. Howard brought us Conan the Cimmerian in 1932, a sullen eyed moody barbarian with a penchant for killing kings, looting for personal gain and generally being an anti-hero.

Additional Ideas (0)

Please register to add an idea. It only takes a moment.

Join Now!!

Gain the ability to:
Vote and add your ideas to submissions.
Upvote and give XP to useful comments.
Work on submissions in private or flag them for assistance.
Earn XP and gain levels that give you more site abilities.
Join a Guild in the forums or complete a Quest and level-up your experience.
Comments ( 12 )
Commenters gain extra XP from Author votes.

October 21, 2011, 1:58
Update: Intended as a defense of common fantasy settings, got bored with writing it.
February 7, 2012, 18:43
That is funnier and more insightful then the entire article.
February 7, 2012, 23:36
It was relevant at the time in the forum, but as I delved into the issue it revealed itself to be topical. Genre fantasy works because it's familiar.
Voted Mourngrymn
October 22, 2011, 14:14
While I see nothing largely constructive about this I see a purpose. After reading this I realize what I've known all along when writing Hewdamia, that I wanted different as everything is the same. When bottom line Hewdamia is no different. I have no elves or dwarves or orcs, but my Derevo, Gison, and Oba'ke closely resembles them even with intending.

I think this is a good read to put what we (I) do in perspective and realize where it all comes from. Break the mold and go left field for your next sub and make it truly unique.
October 22, 2011, 15:12
This is only about 20% of what I fully intended to write, what the path of modern generic fantasy is and where it came from. After writing this much I pretty much figured that it was a purely mental exercise that no one would really care much about.
August 1, 2012, 18:32
That's a shame really. I would have liked to read the rest.
October 22, 2011, 18:44

That's the thing about archetypes, they're the first and foremost things that we think of, the primordial fears and dreams. Elves are mystery and alluring, something beyond human nature and control. Dwarves are the earth, solind, ever-present, and generally benign. Orcs are our memories of the past, of days when tribal warfare was common, and of the dark side of nature.

Dragons skirt the boundary of good and evil, being either deadly or benign. Either way, they are often set as the most powerful of mortal forces, the greatest threat or aid to man, our greatest challenge.

And these archetypes have been in  existence since man first learned to dream, present in every culture in some form or another. They are the tales of childhood, and the dreams we long to have again. They are that which everyone tries to find, an incarnation of imagination

Voted EmilioV
August 1, 2012, 18:33
It's a well written (if unfinished) article. Something we can all relate to.
Voted axlerowes
January 6, 2013, 12:19
you should seek to forge your excellent ideas and insights in the crucible of academic debate.
Voted valadaar
February 13, 2013, 13:16
I liked where this was going and was mildly disappointed when it ended mid-stream.

Voted Moonlake
January 31, 2015, 19:39
I can certainly relate to what this article says about the attraction of fantasy to me.
Voted Woofer295
November 10, 2017, 9:39
It's good to be reminded of the staples of the worldbuilding trade. Very grounding.


Random Idea Seed View All Idea Seeds

Magic Rush

       By: Cheka Man

Magic is addictive, small spells are like cannabis in addictiveness, major ones are like cocaine or herion. Many countrys ban even cantrips as a result.

Ideas  ( System ) | January 20, 2009 | View | UpVote 3xp

Creative Commons License
Individual submissions, unless otherwise noted by the author, are licensed under the
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License
and requires a link back to the original.

We would love it if you left a comment when you use an idea!
Powered by Lockmor 4.1 with Codeigniter | Copyright © 2013 Strolen's Citadel
A Role Player's Creative Workshop.
Read. Post. Play.
Optimized for anything except IE.