Strolen\s Citadel content. 
Hobbit Chair and Eat Racing
Systems  (Societal/ Cultural)   (Specific)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-15 05:42 PM
+0.5 for being part of the Freetext Friday and like Muro said, just cute and a "ready-to-drop" element for the Shire. Go to Comment
The Broken Peace
Plots  (Discovery)   (Single-Storyline)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-02-15 12:08 AM
I like the premise of this sub where the PCs get a chance to find out about the misconception about goblins are driving actions that are actually not benevolent but they thought were. Go to Comment
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-15 05:09 PM
*jumps into the conversation upon hearing own name* Well, I never thought about the voting business because I posted in such a way purely because I myself have an aversion to reading works of length on the site so I posted in Chapters format for easy reading.

I'm yet to read the Earth part (spent whole of yesterday practically in chat). Axle, you sure that the jumbled dialogue is intentional as opposed to the product of this being a Drunken Guild sub? :P Go to Comment
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-15 05:39 PM
Okay, just finished. The intentionally odd dialogue wasn't so bad overall but at the start it wasn't clear to me that Emily spoke that way because of the Serimax (I originally thought it was just a med for your nerves as opposed to sth like the dope that could get you high) and so I thought that was just a product of this being a Oekaki thing that seems to be your normal mode of operation.

I like the action packed start and the odd bit there indicating Emily was high on sth. Sci-fi normally isn't my thing but this so far I can handle (why I can't handle sci fi usually is b/c of drawn out explanations of how all the awesome tech works, they flow over my head and I just cannot comprehend).

Nothing much to fix in my opinion except regarding clarity in the early part of Emily's odd speech and the question marks currently missing across the board (very consistent behaviour for someone drunk :P). Go to Comment
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-15 05:46 PM
Well, I'm one crazy person that never subscribed to this rule so didn't know how many like me are there :P Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 11
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-10 05:42 PM
Update: Still a draft 1 version but one already been through 2 once-overs. Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 11
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-12 12:27 AM
"She had told all to him, again withholding the parts too out-of-place...."
Here I meant that she did not tell Temujin the bits about her coming from another world, only about her amnesia and the Bride Test. Clarified wording to make this clear.

Well, I sort of left it vague but in my mind, they only kissed on the night described in scene 1.

In my current plans, this dimensional jumping business will pretty much end here in the sense of how it occurred etc. will not be explained until the very end (but it was definitely not planned). The only place where it will come on popping up is in Bortai's thoughts and her value judgments.
Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 11
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-12 04:30 PM
Well, I did mention the ambush in passing in scene 2 but in hindsight, I know what you mean. Thanks for always pointing out these jarring aspects that I wouldn't see myself because I'm still caught up in the thrall of writing the story.

By conversation, I assume you meant the interaction b/w the 2 protagonists as opposed to exchanges at the Yorgu. I think I understand where you remark comes from. To be honest, I found that it's something naturally arising out of my writing and I did think that it might be a writing flaw of me (did I mention that I write on a kind of thought-of-consciousness basis where it's almost like my internal muse writing rather than me consciously writing?) I think I mentioned earlier that I found I have a habit of truncating conversation and replace it with Bortai's internal thoughts and problem is when I read it straight afterwards, I couldn't get conversation back in again. In this particular instance, Bortai is basically covering the same things that she already told Temujin's parents in last Chap so you see how then the actual content of the conversation wounds up as repetition in my mind.

About the word consummation, I agree that it does mean sex in a conventional sense but it just always means something different to me personally. To me, the consummation of love is just about the confirmation of mutual love and an action that seals it. I guess it's a reflection of my cultural background where sex is a less liberal topic than in Western cultures. I'm not sure that I really care that any of my ESB readers will interpret this differently than me the author. Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 11
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-12 09:08 PM
I agree that clarity is one major aspect that I need to work on in terms of writing, regardless of the form. I will look through my editing checklist once I finish this whole book and see that clarity is improved across the board. I was merely stating that I care a little less about the romance section here as author because I do not see romance as the main selling point of this book (or as author, I just don't care much about it.) Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 11
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-13 06:19 PM
Actually, the ambush ties into the overall arc of good vs evil in this story and going back over this Chap over the last week or so, I did realise that like you said, I’ve underplayed the significance of the loss of the two horses which just doesn’t sit well with this particular society. As for the lives, not sure how to work it into the story at this point (and I never thought about it either so I'm glad you raised it) but one of the Crunalan dogmas is “Do honour onto the blood of your kin and foe alike.” Part of what was meant in the latter part was that bloodshed is acceptable (and actually encouraged) in this society as long as certain aspects impinging on the concept of honour was observed.

Not sure about what you meant here by “reversing the Bride Test”.
Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 11
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-13 09:22 PM

It was the reverse part that I did not get but I think I've got it now, you are basically saying that it's the reverse since Bortai is chasing after Temujin now.

Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 11
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-16 09:12 PM

Thanks for this feedback, again very valuable to me. What I was attempting to do in scene 2 was to revive the sense of threat to the party after the lovers coming together in scene 1. (Then scene 1 of next Chap builds on this scene (or is meant to) and takes the conflict higher.) But ugh.... I will see how I could fix this scene on my 2nd draft for this book.

Yes, I'm trying to drop bits about their culture here and there, as much as possible (that's why I personally love fantasy at any rate). I've never read Moby Dick before or even heard about the Cup of Gold (but I can tell you I can never finish Treasure Island, not even the kids' version but then I was reading a Chinese translation so that's a contributing factor as well). I'm currently re-reading Lord of Rings to learn from this absolute fav or mine but yes, Moby Dick will now be on my reading list. Cup of Gold? I have to read the abstract to see if it interests me enough to pick it up. There're classics that I simply cannot abide.

Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 11
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-16 09:24 PM
I see, I did primary school back in HK and no required reading for us except actual textbook there.
Just read the abstract of Cup of Gold on Goodreads, not too off-putting. But then I borrow from local library and so can only get my hands on it if lib actually stocks it. Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 3
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-09 10:41 PM

Update: whole Chap revised continuing from expansion of sub-plot starting from last scene of Chap 2.

Go to Comment
The Holy Hovercraft of The Ice Bears
Society/ Organizations  (Religious)   (World Wide)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-09 05:29 PM
Glad to be of service :P Go to Comment
The Holy Hovercraft of The Ice Bears
Society/ Organizations  (Religious)   (World Wide)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-09 05:10 PM
I see that this is the stub you were referring to in the chat the other day. The historical context here is intriguing to me but I am satisfied already by what was already put down. The title was a bit of a mismatch to actual content but then I'm fine with it as it is since it is the historical context section that is the sole interest for me (you know how I'm not a sci-fi person but what you put down under the actual crafts I can handle, any more and my brain would unravel :P) . Besides, I still don't know how changing title name with it being included in the permanent link really works.

Like Muro, I can well see that once you get down into the nitty-gritty of how this sect manages to hold this planet against all the others who want access to the mines and personages of note within the sect, you will have a full sub on your hands that this was just the beginning of. I don't see straight away how this sect is likely to be changed by their military control of this planet and the subsequent conflicts that arise (I always find evolution within a society more interesting than just the history of how it all started but that's personal taste). You might or might not wish to delve into this aspect. Go to Comment
The War Field
NPCs  (Minor)   (Agricultural)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-06 12:39 AM
Certainly an interesting piece that you have developed and very flavourful. It is interesting that you decided to put this under Characters instead of a Fiction piece though. For me, the strongest bit that comes out of this piece is not the characterisation but more the part about civilian agriculturists' attitude to war but it could be just me. Anyway, the characterisation is quite high quality given stated aim of the piece and Oekaki. Go to Comment
31 years IRL(33 ish!) of my Mysantia Campaign
Articles  (Campaign)   (Game Mastering)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-03 07:08 PM
As you requested, a comment but no actual vote. I skipped over some of the contents b/c some of the content is just too game-specific for a non-gamer for me but I read most of it.

Firstly, personally I am indifferent to whether this is a sub or a forum thread (on a theoretical level). I think the main reason of why you're getting a low score is because as it is, this sub appears to be in draft form like you are typing up your experience in stream-of-consciousness notes form and haven't tidied any of it up. If you don't feel like tidying it up at all, then it's prob. better in the forums. The actual content is fine as far as I could tell since this is your memoir and I can see that it is filled with a lot of information of personal gaming experience etc and has a logical structure talking thru how you first started and then going by chronological order of your progression.

In your subs so far, I find the formatting has always been a little less than what is to my liking. I know you capital all your titles but can you bold the headers and also put an extra line between sections? No big issue but just makes the subs more reader friendly. Not sure whether you work from Word or not but if you do, copy and pasting from Word to the Input Sub page still retains the formatting if you just have bolded headers and plain text. If you want to start looking at somewhat more advanced formatting (different sized headings, putting text in boxes, inserting a page break etc.), take a look at Strolen's CSS Demonstration sub accessible through the "I am Helping" link under the Library drop-down menu.
Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 10
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-01 06:48 PM
I might rewrite the last scene because it seemed a bit implausible that the ambushers did not come with their own mounts in this setting. Not sure whether characterisation is improving or not but I'm starting to think that it will be an endemic problem until I finish the whole book and let it cool down enough so that I can go over again and specifically re-write particular parts to add in characterisation. Go to Comment
The Return of the White Deer- Chapter 10
Articles  (Fiction)   (Gaming - Genre)
Moonlake's comment on 2015-01-09 02:34 AM
What you mentioned about the romance bit and the possibility that she might not find such a dream match for her in the teenager Temujin as she had in the other dimension was interesting. I haven't thought of it at all even though it's quite logical. To be honest, I've always had an aversion for pure romance stories despite my gender so I guess I never thought of using their romance as an instrument to generate conflict (and also I guess at the end of the day, I'm all for happy endings and I feel that it's a little cruel to inflict a broken dream on Bortai after her experience in modern days).

As for taking votes seriously, I agree that sometimes I do not take 3s that well, thinking that it means that commenters think that I've written a mundane/mediocre sub but recently I've changed my mindset (after all, a 3 I gave to a sub isn't a bad score from my point of view, I'm still praising its content as solid, I'm just a little soft-hearted most of the time when I comment and when it comes my turn to be voted on, tend to have wishful thinking about people finding something more to give it a 3.5 rather than simple 3). However, I'm also genuinely interested in comments for themselves as well. Like you said, your thoughts on the underlying idea of the sub, how I developed the idea and other thoughts and feelings you have about it. I think those are the true gems of the Citadel and to have a lot of Only voted comments sometimes upset me. That happened to one of my other Dragon Empire sub and it practically gnawed on me until a comment from the other Moon (Mystic, not Hunter, too many Moons around the Citadel) soothed me.

Anyway, your comments have really helped me so far and now I truly feel that this book (as of current version saved in my PC) is getting more worthy of public consumption. Will be bugging Strolen to change sub names for me tomorrow so that I can release more Chaps that are currently sitting in my PC idle. Go to Comment
Total Comments:

Join Now!!

Mimic Blade

       By: Woofer295

A Mimic in the rather unconventional form of a weapon, can be used as a weapon and grows more powerful over time. If introduced to the party early it could make an unexpected betrayal. Skittering around like a terrifying insect.

Ideas  ( Items ) | November 5, 2017 | View | UpVote 3xp