Game Mastering
12 Votes


Hits: 6571
Comments: 14
Ideas: 0
Rating: 4.0833
Condition: Normal
ID: 1275


May 20, 2011, 5:00 am

Vote Hall of Honour
Cheka Man

You must be a member to use HoH votes.
Author Status


Treasure. It happens


Treasure is both the bane and boon of gaming campaigns. The purpose of all this was to bring up some more obvious, but often overlooked, types of treasure. The focus too often is on gold, gems, and magic items when the fun could be enriched by recognizing some awkward, but just as valuable, alternate items. Don’t pass up that ornately carved throne gathering dust in the lair of ogres. Don’t pass up that odd colored flower that your character has never seen. Take it all with you. You never know what you might get for it.

It is unavoidable. Sometimes it comes from the thrill of victory. Sometimes it is just plain annoying. Sometimes it is the only reason for the adventure. Regardless of your view of treasure it is inevitable. Once the carnage is over the pilfering begins. How much does he have on him? Is it magical? What does it do? Oh no, not more copper. Treasure can quickly lose its excitement for the tired DM that wants to concentrate on the story and for the PCs who quickly get bored with ‘more coins’ or ‘more gems’ or ‘more magical weapons.’ Okay, maybe not so much the magical weapons part but that is another debatable subject.

Treasure should be fun and exciting. Maybe not all the time because ogres probably don’t have much more then half eaten copper and sticks on them, but treasure can be much more creative and the game will thank you for it.

Arguably the most common type of treasure and rightfully so. It is small, universal, and everybody has it.

But coins can be much more then “you find 100 gold pieces.”
ephemeralstability had a great idea on changing the shape of the currency used . Take a look at that here.  Basically each coin would take its own distinct geometric shape.

Maybe there were different monetary systems that were once used by have long ago fallen into disuse. Perhaps the money is minted with the current king or his symbol on it. Through time the value of a coin with a hero king of the past on it is worth twice as much as a current coin and conversely a evil king of the past, his coin could be totally rejected. So when they find coin they can find the same coin with different symbols that greatly affect their value.

If hero king copper coins in bulk are found on a group of ogres you know they found something. And ogres probably have somebody ordering them about, and they very well may have the real valuable hero king gold coins…could be a hook.

There also could be money minted in different lands and by different races as well that may change the worth.

You don’t want to get too complicated because the system still has to be quick and shouldn’t take over the game, but adding a little bit of extra to the standard gold coin can bring back the excitement in finding another copper coin.

Gems and Jewels
Well, they are what they are and if anybody can be more creative with these please chime in. They don’t always have to be found in a perfect already cut state. In a mining area or cave they can be found in their most ugliest and almost unrecognizable form. A gem crafter could immediately see the inherent value in the piece of discolored rock as could a PC with that skill.

Probably the best thing about gems is that the value can fluctuate so much from one shop to the next. Reasons for this can vary greatly. Ignorance or dishonesty of the shop keeper, market saturation and the rarity of the gem, and quality of the gem itself. In many cases many identical gems may fetch a higher price because they can be used to create matching jewelry.

Useable/Tradeable/Common Items
These may not carry the most valuable prices but they are everywhere and can always be used to make a few bucks. These are the things that you find at the general, and not so general store, and there is always some sort of demand for them somewhere.
For instance: tapestries, rugs, fireplace grates, candles and candlesticks, tables and chairs, pots and pans, statues, door locks (on that door you just kicked/burned down), etc, etc.

There are other more bulky items too. Bags of grain or rice from the kitchen, barrels of ale or wine, maybe they had some livestock in pigs, cows, goats, or chickens (lots of fun trying to get those to the village to sell), statues, doors you didn’t destroy that have that ornate carving that always seems to be in evil guys homes, chandelier, stained glass windows.

Just look around you or go through the price list of whatever gaming book you use and see how many things of value that you pass up every adventure.

Transporting it can be a challenge in itself. I had one group that took a wagon whenever we fought evil and took a wagon full of stuff with us when we left. There are magical opportunities to transport these goods as well.

The problem, like gems, is getting a good value for your hard work.

What about the evil man’s castle itself. Does it have a prior owner that kicked them out that may want this stuff you are taking? Do the ones that cleaned the tower get ownership of it and therefore 1) use it as their new base home 2) sell it for insane profit?

Books and Papers
If you killed a wizard, you probably have something. Found his tower, you have even more. Doesn’t have to be a wizard. Anybody with money and an interest in something may collect books or papers on the subject. Might give an extra dimension to the person you just defeated when the evil mass murderer loved epic tales and songs of love.

Culled from a note I had from long ago, perhaps papers and documents are found that show that a king that took the throne after an assassination really shouldn’t be king. Proof that such and such was chosen to be next king but it was taken from him with backdoor politics or something. Perhaps another document signed by long dead kings show that land was granted to certain dukes but the land was really given to their enemies. A few questions asked of correct people shows that there has always been rumors of these things but nothing that could ever be proven…until now.

The problem is finding a buyer that knows its worth.

Magic Items
I really don’t think I want to delve into this one. There are many different opinions on this subject and a few thread discussing it. Needless to say I have an entire section dedicated to magic items so you can use any of these as inspiration for this topic.

Animals and Plants
Alive or dead, mundane or exotic, there is very often somebody that wants something.

Already mentioned livestock that would otherwise be abandoned. Found a liter of puppies or wolves, somebody would see the value of getting them and training them. Exotic birds, alive or dead for their feathers. Alchemists are always in the market for exotic ingredients. Claws of wyverns, teeth of dragons, whatever. If you killed an exotic creature of any type, don’t waste that effort, salvage everything you can off it. At the very least it may be worth a mug of ale at the tavern when you tell your tale and then display a collection of teeth and claws.

Plants can be used to. Adventures take you to exotic places that few travel to without need. While there perhaps there could be some useful fauna that could be collected and used. Rare plants or fungi living deep in caves, new kind of vine leaves that eat human flesh, trees that grow perfectly straight (chop down a few to sell for staffs, arrows, or longbows), or even spring water could be valuable (how much do we spend now on ‘bottled spring water’ when we have a tap in our kitchen?).

All this stuff is great, but if there is no market then it might as well be firewood…although there is probably a market for that as well.

It takes a little extra initial planning by the players and DM but with some research they will be able to find out what some of the items are in this location that people want. DM could simply make a chart of the things or use the item price guide in the book and randomly roll to find a few items of need in each town. Alchemist may be short on Werewolf blood and the general store is running low on grain. Once these notes start being taken they take on a life of their own. The PCs start to know what is valuable and worth salvaging and as they go through different towns they can sell information to a grain merchant with surplus that such and such town is low on grain. Soon the players will be like self proclaimed antique road show professionals able to quote prices and understand market trends. Gold loses its flavor and they are now looking for a 7 foot table with lion claw table legs. Soon the search for demons to kill loses its flavor in the hope of finding a rare color of silk in the market for cheap. Well, maybe not.


The purpose of all this was to bring up some more obvious, but often overlooked, types of treasure. The focus too often is on gold, gems, and magic items when the fun could be enriched by recognizing some awkward, but just as valuable, alternate items. Don’t pass up that ornately carved throne gathering dust in the lair of ogres. Don’t pass up that odd colored flower that your character has never seen. Take it all with you. You never know what you might get for it.

Additional Ideas (0)

Please register to add an idea. It only takes a moment.

Suggested Submissions

Join Now!!

Gain the ability to:
Vote and add your ideas to submissions.
Upvote and give XP to useful comments.
Work on submissions in private or flag them for assistance.
Earn XP and gain levels that give you more site abilities.
Join a Guild in the forums or complete a Quest and level-up your experience.
Comments ( 14 )
Commenters gain extra XP from Author votes.

Voted Ancient Gamer
November 7, 2005, 19:13
Good stuff Strolen
Voted Michael Jotne Slayer
February 22, 2006, 13:11
Ah, I love to read stuff like this. No matter how many times a GM have thought of these things and executed them it will always be rewarding to read an article like this. Refreshing thoughts Strolen.
Voted Mourngrymn
May 25, 2006, 16:20
This has always been a good idea...

One other thing I have gifted my players with are henchmen. Not neccessarily the ones they wanted.

I had a character in one of my groups who showed a great display of power and awed a gobliny creature. This creature followed him around and began bringing him gifts of food and coins and anything it could find. Everyone wanted ot kill it but being as it did nothing wrong and did not show any form of malicious acts they kept it around.

He was a nice bump in the road as the character hated it, it was against his morals to have an evil type creature following him and calling him master. However the more good aligned characters kept telling him it was bad to murder an innocent. It was laughable to say the least.
Voted Cheka Man
May 26, 2006, 12:26
Henchemen/women/creatures are useful.
Voted Kinslayer
January 30, 2008, 16:32
What? I haven't voted for this little gem yet? Let me fix that right now...
Voted MoonHunter
January 30, 2008, 23:52
Ditto what Kinslayer said. I thought I had voted on everything that made the move. I guess not.
Voted valadaar
January 31, 2008, 10:31
A good article - handy even.
Voted Kuseru Satsujin
May 31, 2008, 19:59
One of the things I like to use for treasure are mundane upgrades to weapons, armor, and equipment (that is, in addition to the above alternatives).
Voted Xamusel
June 1, 2008, 21:16
It actually was a good idea for a good article of sorts. Keep it up, Strolen, for you are doing a GREAT job!!!!
Voted tinypoisonousfish
January 9, 2010, 20:44
Nice piece here. One of my favorite treasures is mundane books, especially lost epic works, medical treatises, ancient glass making or steel making techniques, and histories where a dark age and revealed history takes on very significant relevance. Hidden and alternate histories (or better, bygone heresies) are good too, so are medieval style psalters and codexes with numerous books inside of wildly varying subjects. Some of these things could potentially change the course of history, with the heroes at the center.

Another gag I pulled on my players was gifting them with a primitive warrior after they had saved an island tribe from multiple dangers. This man was a capable fighter but he wasn't resistant as they were to certain diseases, and of course he had an entirely different cultural perspective. Great cause and effect game.
August 20, 2010, 19:43
This is a very nice piece of work, whenever Roleplaying games are played they commonly find Gold and Magic items and what not. What's the chances you're going to find a Magic sword on a Goblin? Or what's the chances of finding over 300 gold pieces on a beggar?
Voted Dossta
October 8, 2010, 13:47

To be honest, I find the idea of turning an RPG into a market sim to be . . . distasteful.  Yes, treasure can be unique and interesting.  Yes, we should know how the market will react to said interesting treasure should the players try to pull something like this off.
However, when I describe a forest that "burbles with the sound of a clear spring-fed stream, flowing between rows of trees that grow perfectly straight as the sweet scent of rare, golden flowers permeates the air", I don't want my players to be thinking about how they can sell it all.  Perhaps I'm being unfair, but it seems to me that encouraging this behavior would only detract from the game.  If anything, I would use the contents of this post to make it as hard as possible for my players to find buyers for their plundered draperies, candlesticks, doorways and stained glass windows.
This is not to say that treasure should all be gold coins, jewels and the like.  I just don't want my world turned into a giant flea market, in which every stone, every flower is judged by its market value.  This is still a very well-written, well-presented article, and I appreciated the read.  Even though I disagree with the premise, it gave me a lot to think about.

July 17, 2011, 15:21

One idea shared with me was to actually give a picture of the gem to the player. If it's a semi-precious stone you most likely have one or can buy a small bag of them for a couple dollars. Gems are shiny. Really shiny. It's something you don't appreciate when the DM says "you have a 300 GP ruby" until you are looking at a $300 ruby. Beyond rubies, what does an adventurine look like? There are thousands of valuble stones you can use to add flavor. 

Voted caesar193
August 24, 2012, 13:42
Why not simply throw equipment onto the list? The party archer could use a sheaf of arrows the ogres didn't need. The party warrior could use a back up sword in case he loses his club. Even a pile of torches could be a good treasure, especially if the bottom level lacks lighting.

Link Backs

Random Idea Seed View All Idea Seeds

       By: ephemeralstability

The Forest of Throck:

Throck forest is divided into three parts: a region of twisted black magic, which is dark and hemmed in with the legions of sable pine. This is Spindel, and is occupied by the hideous Ettercaps and their spider-pets. The second area is the chaotic elfin-wood, where the druids work their wyrd magic amongst the oaks. The last part is Udnalor, the home of the gnomes. Finding themselves surrounded by these chaotic forces they dwell as quietly as possible beneath the surface. Their culture is a fascinating one to visit, and in the next few miscellaneous ideas, I shall examine the ways and customs of THE GNOMES OF UDNALOR, with a view to role-playing them.

Ideas  ( Locations ) | May 4, 2002 | View | UpVote 2xp

Creative Commons License
Individual submissions, unless otherwise noted by the author, are licensed under the
Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License
and requires a link back to the original.

We would love it if you left a comment when you use an idea!
Powered by Lockmor 4.1 with Codeigniter | Copyright © 2013 Strolen's Citadel
A Role Player's Creative Workshop.
Read. Post. Play.
Optimized for anything except IE.