Strolen\s Citadel content. 
Shelandra Batwind
NPCs  (Minor)   (Mystical)
RGTraynor's comment on 2010-08-01 07:04 AM
Heh, I wish I'd seen this before. This is hilarious. Go to Comment
The Dunshar
Lifeforms  (Intelligent Species)   (Any)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-05-25 10:59 AM

This is pretty cool.  My campaign is already race-heavy, but this would be a sweet addition to many a milieu.  Well done.

Go to Comment
Plaza of the Bell
Locations  (Neighborhoods)   (Any)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-05-26 01:40 AM

Heh, it wouldn't take a fiendish mind to conceive of this: the lethal potential of being at the summit of a belltower when the bell's sounding forth is a trope I've seen more than once in fiction.  An interesting visual nonetheless, and a fairly gruesome public execution method.

Go to Comment
Mitrall Cult
Society/ Organizations  (Religious)   (Regional)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-04-12 04:11 AM

A good start, I think.  I've some questions.

* "Mitrall was a Guardian Deity of the Dead ..." Is there a sense that the deity doesn't exist any more, or is this from a campaign that doesn't have interventionist deities?

* Obviously the Cult is very strong, if it has the resources claimed.  Is this organization particularly prestigious in its society, or does it have particularly strong backers?  Is its scope local or international?

* If the worship of Mitrall is no longer an aspect of the Cult, does the organization still call itself a "Cult," as opposed to a society/sodality/order?

* Plainly it's well-organized ... but how?  Is there a hierarchy?  A cell structure?  Is it a secret society, or are some of its workings public?

Go to Comment
Mitrall Cult
Society/ Organizations  (Religious)   (Regional)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-04-13 02:03 AM
Ah, but putting my comments in "Ideas" would have meant putting my own spin on it, rather than hearing what your take on them was! Thanks for the answers. Go to Comment
Manor Home D'Marsarac
Locations  (Fortification)   (Mountains)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-07-04 06:29 PM

I like this a lot.  Obviously, I'm with the vox populi (however much six years ago).  People have been coming up with material for RPGs for 35 years now, and I'm sick to death of the premise that everything has to be Unique! Snazzy! Unusual!  Well, no, not everything is, and not everything has to have Dark Cultists, Peasants With A Secret, Puttering Old Men Who Are Really Archmages and the like.  For my money, I'll take something calm and low-key that will fit into my world ... and if I feel like tossing in something offbeat, well, what in the merry hell prevents me from doing that?

Go to Comment
Of Roses and Thorns
Plots  (Duty)   (Multi-Storyline)
RGTraynor's comment on 2009-11-17 08:15 PM
Excellent plot seed.

And though it's years down the road, just on the offchance people will see it, here's my take on Monument's comment: it's the moral equivalent of threadcrapping.

Seriously now ... should I barge in on any submission in a genre I don't play, a style I don't like or a milieu I don't use and slam it with an artificially low rating for NO other reason than it's not useful to me? Why would I do that? Go to Comment
The Temple of the First Man
Locations  (Establishment)   (Forest/ Jungle)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-04-12 09:36 AM

Not bad, if a lot for what boils down to a "safe place of refuge."  A tick off for formatting and the occasional typo.

Go to Comment
Nice to Meet You
Plots  (Coincidence)   (Campaign)
RGTraynor's comment on 2010-07-13 08:39 AM
Yeah, were I to vote on it, it'd be rock bottom. Go to Comment
The Green Sword
Items  (Melee Weapons)   (Magical)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-06-23 08:12 AM

Very munchkinesque.  This would have fit in perfectly well - typos and bad writing included - in D&D dungeoneering products circa 1978.  How sloppy is this?  Let me count the ways.

* No clear break between the past history and the original history.

* Why would using the sword in the original battle (which that manipulative bastard of an archmage set up in the first place) be considered "cheating?"  Exactly how were those students fighting - presumably to the death - otherwise?

* For a sword that purportedly seeks to strike a balance, it sure seems dedicated to punking out "evil."

* If no one's owned this after the "good" student, it's what, been sitting in that cave ever since?  Then who's been calling it the "Green Sword?"  Something that isn't in the public eye doesn't attract nicknames.

* The powers are completely munchkinesque.  Who would know to call the spirits in the sword?  Why would anyone imagine you could do that, without the metagaming info?

(Never mind that I hate alignment with a hot, heavy hate.)

Go to Comment
Sima Ling
NPCs  (Major)   (Religious)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-06-25 03:04 AM

Heck, the "Old Fears Come Again" plot hook's enough for a high vote, all in of itself.  Too damn often, the moral absolutism of D&D and its ilk manifests itself in the notion that if the other guys are "Evil," just about any bestial thing you do to them is okay, because, well, they're Evil, doncha know?

Go to Comment
Timtom Flyboy Butterfoot's Flying Machine
Items  (Other)   (Magical)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-05-28 06:51 AM

Nice start, good flavor text, but too much we don't know.  What's its duration?  How fast can it go?  (Heck, how do you steer the thing?)  How many times a day can it be used?  Exactly how sturdy is that wagon?

Go to Comment
Roots of Unity
Items  (Other)   (Non-Magical)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-05-12 03:55 PM

Eh, good for local color, but if they don't actually do anything ... ?  If you can't chip or work them, by the bye, how are they "made?"  Is there any speculation as to what could have formed or fashioned them, beneath the earth?  Something had to separate them from the roots in such teensy slivers, after all.  The creator's been long vanished from the site, but even so ...

Go to Comment
Winter's Bounty
Items  (Transports)   (Heroic)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-03-13 10:32 AM

Happily, I DO GM a game with heavy nautical elements, which is how I've stumbled across this one.  One of the outstanding subs on this site and a terrific idea.

Go to Comment
University of Linnarson
Locations  (Establishment)   (Any)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-05-12 03:58 PM

It's definitely a good start - and yay! to MoonHunter for putting some more meat on the bones - but aside from the Senior Masters, I'd have liked a little more substance to balance the flavor text.

Go to Comment
Shards of the Storm
Items  (Other)   (Campaign Defining)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-03-13 10:34 AM

And another in the same ilk of Winter's Bounty.  Outstanding.

Go to Comment
Dark Lord's Gloves
Items  (Clothes)   (Villanous)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-05-27 06:53 PM

Next to illiterate.

Go to Comment
Kalahars' Gem
Items  (Wand/Staff/ Arcane)   (Magical)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-05-27 06:46 PM

Hrm.  So, let's see: (1) If you put a lot of power into gems it makes gems powerful, (2) Someone did, therefore (3) This gem is uber, (4) The end.

Extremely pedestrian, and combined with the choppy, ungrammatical, misspelled writing style, this was a Not Ready For Prime Time sub.

Go to Comment
Jamil's Bain
Items  (Melee Weapons)   (Magical)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-07-06 05:59 PM

Okay, an interesting idea.  Nothing special.

Go to Comment
Wolve's Revenge
Plots  (Duty)   (Campaign)
RGTraynor's comment on 2011-04-16 10:07 AM

Mm, definitely some questions here, as others have mentioned.

Beyond those ones, I've a simple one - how in the heck did Jerod find out in the first place that this ring allows him to control wolves?  Why would he put it on?  What would lead him to suspect that it's enchanted?  Is he a wizard in his own right, or as MoonHunter speculated, is it some powerful artifact or bound demon which has possessed Jerod?

Go to Comment
Total Comments:

Join Now!!

       By: CaptainPenguin

A cave with weapons sunken into the walls, blades sticking out of the floor and ceiling, and so on. Possibly, any weapon used in it could be torn out of the hand and sink into the stone.

Ideas  ( Dungeons ) | January 25, 2003 | View | UpVote 2xp