Esp. like the deviousness of the last line in this sub. Go to Comment

It's a bit of a teaser (personally, I will put this up as a Stub but that's just me) but the quality of the write-up is good. Go to Comment

An okay sub but would appreciate more details along the lines of previous comments. Go to Comment

Only voted Go to Comment

A good item for introducing random elements to PCs. Go to Comment

A simple but neat twist Go to Comment

A good NPC write-up for a Behind-the-Scenes villain.
*Commented on for the Commenting Challenge Go to Comment

A solid sub for sparking sth large. I like how 3 of the demons are not inherently evil and might be relatively harmless, only somewhat annoying
*Commented on for the Commenting Challenge Go to Comment

A nice evil twist. Go to Comment

I am uncertain how the players would ever get out of the toxin-induced sleep but overall, I think this sub is of okay quality so a 3 it is. Go to Comment

I like this as a minor local legend with potential for much more. I would have liked more details on it but as it is, it's at the high end of my 3.5. Go to Comment

Bonus points for the downsides of the helm
*Commented on for the Commenting Challenge Go to Comment

An innocuous encounter with this NPC has the potential to turn into side-quests or even sth bigger. A simple and good utility sub this is. Go to Comment

Like the trade-off b/w absorbing a magical spell against normal strength of protection.
Like Ramhir, I'm happy with the lightning effect on those with bad alignment.
*Commented on for the Commenting Challenge Go to Comment

Lack of history, while not necessary for it being incorporated in game, is the reason of my vote. Go to Comment

DId you notice when the book was published? Could it be that the author is Nimblefinder? Just curious Go to Comment

Besides this plot seemingly being submitted for the wrong category (I agree this is more of an encounter as opposed to a side-quest but then possibly the author has his own interpretation of what constitutes a side-quest), I think this is a solid submission. Not that original and refreshing in itself but then it did spark nice inputs from others that have added a great deal to it. Go to Comment

This would have been a solid sub and it surely is written okay but like the Captain, the fact that the reason why the mage cursed this seemingly goodness-aligned general is unexplained leaves me with an adverse impression on this particular sub. Go to Comment

Echoing what Dossta said. Go to Comment

This might have been a very old sub submitted in the early days and while this sub is complete, I cannot really view it as a solid sub given the sparsity of details so I will have to vote 2.5 unfortunately. Go to Comment